J. is mortified by the reflexive fatuity with which he associates everything he encounters with some aspect of pop culture. That is, it is as though he is unable to experience anything in its purity, in the exactness of the moment, without mediating it through a system manufactured for television viewing, pop culture at its most degraded and insistent.
W. avoided movies for years because he said he didn’t like the feeling of having his emotions manipulated.
I welcome the assault, a relief from the central narrative, as it were.
But insofar as our own universe become impoverished by comparison, the chicken thawing in a bowl of water in the sink at home when we have just witnessed the resistance fighter share a heel of bread with a smudged, speechless orphan.
J. and I were talking about this after stumbling across the Boathouse in Central Park. It was my first time there, yet as we crossed the threshold into the dining room overlooking the lake and the bank of small wooden boats, I recognized it immediately from a rerun I had seen of “Sex and City,” the one where the heroine and her paramour fall into the water.
So was I robbed somehow, of my experience, by seeing it on television? It would not have been the same if I had read about the Boathouse in a book. Seeing does the greatest damage.
There is nothing that hasn’t been already been seen by someone. On the Internet we can see most things before we experience it, to decide whether or not it is “worth it.” A special effort must be made to avoid knowledge of a particular place, as with the sex of a fetus.
Seeing can be undone by thrusting ourselves upon the landscape.
The Boathouse, then, locked in my mind with a conversation with J. about the tyranny of memory: we don’t choose it; memory chooses us. And so we might title this piece, “In Praise of Repression”: our ability to submerge memory, hold its face down in a bucket of water, torturer reversed.
A less salubrious and more accurate analogy: forcing a balloon to assume a new shape, which results in the swift outgrowth of a frog throat, an angry eruption from an unexpected extremity.
I thought about this a few days later, face down at the
Tui Na joint on Mott Street as a Chinese woman mounted me and dug her knees into my buttocks.